While European countries have been working on ways to achieve more unity, Middle Eastern countries have been busy seeking ways to further separate from each other. Clashes and conflicts have become a common sight in the region due to ethnical and sectarian differences in the population.
Yemen is one of those countries hit by separationist winds. The South Yemen Movement, founded in early 2007, has declared its desire to break away from the North, claiming that the ‘South’s national resources have been exploited by the central government’. To help address the issue, the Yemeni government has chosen to move to a federalized system of governance in order to prevent a breakaway.
According to the plan, Sana is going to be the federal capital city while Aden will be given a different status, as it is a commercial center. Yemen will be officially divided into six states; four states in the north and two in the south to be ruled by their own federal governments. This plan is also said to be giving the states independent judicial and executive powers, and will come into effect if approved with a referendum.
But will this new system really be a solution to the problems of Yemen?
To understand that, we first have to examine what powers will be given to the states and what kind of ties will be built between the states and the federal capital city of Sana. This has yet to be clarified.
Federal governments and unitary governments are the most common methods of administration used in the countries of the world today.
In unitary governments, the country is an inseparable whole. Even if it has cities and provinces, they are merely administrative regions and are governed by officials appointed by the central government. The central government makes administrative, judicial and financial decisions that impact the entire country. This is how the system works currently in Yemen.
In a federal government, the country is divided into multiple states and even if the state seems to stand as one, every state acts like a separate region within itself. They can independently make administrative, judicial and financial decisions and put them into practice. However, their powers are not unlimited; they report to the central government and this level of accountability is regulated by the federal constitution.
In federal systems, the issues that will occur in terms of division of power between federal administrations and the central government usually creates sluggishness in the enforcement of policies that concern the entire country, which in time may turn into large crises.
In federal systems, every state tends to look out for their own interests and naturally, it would be far more difficult to equally distribute the wealth to the entirety of the country. In other words, a shift to a federal system in Yemen has the potential to escalate separatist sentiment, rather than alleviate it. The new states will be shaped by ethnic and sectarian differences. Therefore, it is likely that there will be regional wave of immigration, and ethnic cleansing, which would surely add fuel to the fire.
Even if there are measures that can be taken to prevent states from seceding and turning into independent countries, this happens quite frequently, and if the federalized states are based on ethnical or religious divisions, such as in the case of Quebec in Canada or Kashmir in India, the request to ‘secede’ inevitably comes. Varying levels of economic development also fuel such desires. For instance, Catalonia, which has awell developed industrial base and economy, wishes to break away from Spain claiming that its resources are being used by the other states.
Needless to say, the people of Yemen will decide which option is the best for them after evaluating the pros and cons of all the alternatives being presented to them. No matter what system they choose, every Yemeni should know that being united is a command of Allah for Muslims, and therefore they should unite and set aside their differences. Allah orders Muslims in the Qur’an that they should act in unison as a ‘single community’:
Hold fast to the rope of Allah all together, and do not separate. Remember Allah’s blessing to you when you were enemies and He joined your hearts together so that you became brothers by His blessing. You were on the very brink of a pit of the Fire and He rescued you from it. In this way Allah makes His signs clear to you, so that hopefully you will be guided. (Surah Al ‘Imran, 103)
Preserving the integrity of Yemen within a democratic framework is surely possible through an alliance of good and reasonable people in Yemen, regardless of the system chosen. If Yemen can do this, it will set a great example to the Islamic world. Muslims need unity, not separation. Yemen has a great opportunity ahead: it can be the country that chose the long-awaited union of Muslims, rather than choosing artificial divisions.
Adnan Oktar's article on National Yemen: